Jonathan Fryer

What Exactly Are Families?

Posted by jonathanfryer on Tuesday, 25th December, 2007

When Nick Clegg was elected the new leader of the LibDems, he surprised many members by announcing that he was going to establish a network of ordinary families round the country, people unconnected with mainstream politics, so he could find out what they were thinking. My left eyebrow certainly went up sharply. Not because I don’t think politicians should engage with ‘real people’ — on the contrary — but rather, over his choice of the word ‘families’. It’s not just that the word ‘family’ is more commonly part of the rhetoric of right-wing politicians. It is a fact that these days, fewer than 30% of households in Britain are made up of traditional ‘families’. Indeed, in London especially, the big trend in accommodation patterns has been for single-person dwellings. Shared households reflect all sorts of social patterns and relationships.

I suppose it is inevitable that my mind turns to the ‘family’ question on Christmas Day, which in Britain in particular is the day that families traditionally spend together. Christmas cards, chocolate boxes and the television all maintain the myth that this is what it is all about. Even the Church often ignores the fact that Jesus was born in an extremely unorthodox fashion into a dysfunctional family, whom he later left — urging his followers to do likewise, in search of truth, enlightenment or whatever one wants to call it — never married or had kids (as far as we know). Bully for him, I say, as that was right for him. I am reminded of André Gide, whose writings had a marked influence on my youth, when he pronounced, ‘Familles, je vous hais!’ (even though that author actually adored his mother, to an almost unhealthy degree).

I do not hate families myself. To do so would be silly, as well as unjust, and a form of special pleading from someone who doesn’t have one, up or down (if you see what I mean). And I am truly happy for happy families, where they exist. But on Christmas Day above all, those of us who do not have families, or whose family life is not perfect, who are bereaved, or orphaned, or living in different life situations or arrangements, might be tempted to say to Nick Clegg and others: ‘Yes, consult widely! But please, talk about and to individuals, households and communities, not just families!’

About these ads

9 Responses to “What Exactly Are Families?”

  1. Jo A said

    The english language will catch up eventually Jonathan!

  2. Signor Fryer, I hope you not disrepecting the Family, it most unwise.

  3. Linda Jack said

    Yes Jonathan, you are so right. I have had a lovely day with my huge family, but I also heard on the news of the 1 million elderly people who spent Christmas alone, that is just the elderly, what about all the others? Christmas is a very precious time for me but I am acutely aware that it can also be a time that intensifies pain and loneliness. So, you are right to ask questions about the obsession with families, however important they are. Inclusiveness (which I believe we as Lib Dems all subscibe to)has to include those of us who for whatever reason don’t quite make the mark! So, God bless you and hope you have had a lovely day.

    L

  4. Wilf (Ron) Gavin said

    Although jonathanfryer as a very valid point about Nick Clegg families,its a shame he had to trivilies his comments.His comments & ramblings have all the hallmarks of a true Blairite. Instead of his ramblings on what constitutes families he should be asking how having found them ,1 how does he verify they are ordinary & 2 they are not connected to mainstream politics.

  5. Paula said

    The phrase which really annoys me, and which has crept into political discourse, is “hard working families”. What on earth are they? How can a family be hard working?

  6. [...] I’ve only just noticed that Jonathan Fryer has blogged a measure of justifiable disquiet on [...]

  7. Edna Murphy said

    Jonathan makes very sensible points. Well said.

    It will be interesting to see who these families turn out to be (will they include groupings of people without children, people who are not married, etc etc) and how they are encouraged to engage in a dialogue with the LD leadership.

  8. Barry said

    Happy Xmas, Jonathan!

  9. [...] What exactly are families? on Jonathan Fryer’s blog. What is a family? A flurry of comments followed (including a threat [...]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

 
Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 105 other followers

%d bloggers like this: